Stats
Path length: 4.3 miles
Width: 150 yards
Fatalities: 2
Injuries: 21
Rating: F2
County: Knox
Tornado Path
SPC coordinates: Start/End: 36.10 / -83.77
Corrected Coordinates based on newspaper reports from the Knoxville News-Sentinel and details provided by Sheila Hodge:
Start: 36.016485 / -83.870630 End: 36.060017 / -83.772901
Introduction
By the early morning of April 4, 1974, the Super Tornado Outbreak had dealt most of its rage throughout the Midwestern and Southeastern United States. The remnants of supercell thunderstorms had primarily congealed into a solid wall of severe winds and rain as it pushed into the Appalachian region. In East Tennessee, at least six twisters were documented by the Storm Prediction Center (SPC) after midnight. Most were weak, and casualty numbers were relatively low.
However, one of these funnels proved deadly when it struck a mobile home park near Knoxville, TN. A set of twin infants lost their lives, and 21 people were injured along the path. At the time, it was only the third tornado ever documented in Knox County, and as of this summary’s publication, it is the only one to be fatal.
Summary
At around 1:30 am EDT, what was likely a ferocious Quasi-Linear Convective System (QLCS) roared into the city of Knoxville. A QLCS, as defined by the National Weather Service (NWS), is “a linearly-oriented zone of convection” that may feature “arched/bowed out” segments. Simplified, it is a severe line of thunderstorms capable of producing strong winds, hail, and tornadoes (typically weak and short-lived). They can also extend over 100 miles across.
This particular QLCS featured severe winds and was accompanied by at least one twister as it moved through the Knoxville area. The following will discuss known impacts presented in The Knoxville News-Sentinel at the time. We gathered information from 1974 editions on April 4-6.
Widespread damage occurred across portions of the Knoxville metro. Trees and power lines were reported down from the Norwood area in northwest Knoxville to just north of downtown and then out to Mascot, east of the city. Power outages knocked radio stations WETE and WNOX off the air. A varying amount of structural damage occurred, with some of the worst happening in a small mobile home park off Rutledge Pike.
Chris Hale, manager of the Brannon Estates apartment complex off Wilson Road, told the Knoxville Sentinel on April 4 that he thought a tornado hit his area. “I saw a big black cloud coming, and I grabbed my two kids and threw them into the bathroom.” The roofs were torn away from seven apartment buildings, and the interiors were water-logged.
Approximately 2.5 miles east-northeast of Brannon Estates, part of the roof at Christenberry Junior High School (now an elementary school) was snatched, and classes were canceled on April 4.
In our research, we did not find damage reports from downtown and points south. However, a 55-mph wind gust was observed in nearby Alcoa at McGhee Tyson Airport. Along North Broadway in Knoxville, Dixie Kitchen Distributors, about 0.75 north of “The Marble City,” had their roof swept onto the street below, snarling traffic until it was cleared.
Further east, the Knoxville Municipal Zoo was hit. Guy L. Smith III, the director at the time, told the paper that several chickens were killed, and trees and power lines were blown over. The Zoo was closed temporarily for cleanup. Power was lost at the Jacob Building in nearby Chilhowee Park. This structure became an emergency shelter and was among the first to have power restored.
It is difficult to distinguish much of the upheaval from Brannon Estates to the Zoo between a possible tornado and straight-line winds. As the storm pushed further east-northeast, there seemed to be a higher concentration of more intense damage along Rutledge Pike. We are making an educated guess that a QLCS tornado formed somewhere beyond the Zoo and tracked northeast for at least four miles. Widespread wind damage was still occurring within the immediate surroundings of the twister at this point as well. At the residence of Lynn Burnett at 5512 East Sunset Road, there was a report of a tree on the home. This is approximately two miles east-southeast of Rutledge Pike, and we don’t include this in the tornado’s damage path.
Just northeast of our starting point, The Knoxville News-Sentinel reported, “It is easy to track the path of the tornado along Rutledge Pike. Trees are uprooted, signs blown down or damaged, and other trees have jagged scars from limbs torn away from the trunk.” Mrs. Jerry Hillard, who lived on Roosevelt Road off Rutledge Pike, told the paper about the damage to her property. “The wind lifted a utility shed over the Volkswagen parked next to it, demolishing the shed and not touching the car. The wind also ripped out a bolted-in air conditioner at the Hillard home.” Neil Hargis resided nearby, off Lincoln Drive. Three trees were uprooted and the back bedroom of the home was wrecked.
Approximately four miles northeast of the Hillard and Hargis homes was the Rutledge Pike Mobile Home Park along McMillan Station Road. The property owners were William and Anna Kate Coram. The worst damage from the twister occurred at the trailer court, which sat on a small hill.
At least 25 homes sustained damage. Several were obliterated while others rolled downhill and came to rest along other units. A few others were shifted from their foundation.
Edwin Morris, his wife Brenda, and their 4-week-old twins, Tabetha and Edwin Jr, lived in one of the mobile homes. The latter pair’s stepsiblings, James, Elizabeth, and Shirley Dense, were also there. The tornado devastated the Morris’ trailer and tragically, the twin infants were killed. The other three children sustained injuries and were hospitalized. James was still in serious condition a few days after the disaster. Tabetha and Edwin Jr. were buried together on the afternoon of April 5 in Holly Hills Memorial Gardens.
Robert Vancel, 15, was sound asleep when he awoke to the sound of thunder. “I felt the trailer being lifted. I screamed and then passed out. When I came to, rain was hitting on my face. Mother and my two brothers were pinned beneath a wall.” The roar also stirred Robert’s mother, Jenny, from her slumber. She looked out the window and saw “a funnel-shaped cloud coming.” She told the paper that she ran to the room where her youngest sons, Harley and Scott, were and threw herself on top of Harley. After the tornado passed, the Vancels went to University Hospital to be treated for their injuries.
The vacant mobile home of Pat Lemon and his family was found in pieces in a nearby field. Most of it was hanging from the tops of several trees.
The city dump was located adjacent to the trailer park. Just west of that location, a barn on a small hill had its roof torn away. A shack at the dump’s entrance was obliterated.
After leaving the Rutledge Pike Mobile Home Park, it is unclear how extensive the damage was to the northeast. We have no definitive reports of damage; there are just general mentions along Rutledge Pike, possibly to the Mascot area.
Recovery
Per the Red Cross, 21 people were injured and needed hospital treatment, with six being admitted. Approximately 40 volunteer and regular staff workers with the Red Cross were assigned to help the Knox County residents affected by the storm. The Knoxville Utilities Board reported that at the height of the storms that night, about 50% of residents were without power. All but 5% were restored by Noon on April 4, and all had power by April 5. An emergency shelter was set up in Andrew Johnson Hotel and one family affected in the trailer park stayed there. Other families stayed with family members or friends.
Finding the Mobile Home Park
When the Tornado Talk team decides to write about an event, we take the time and due diligence to research as much as possible to get the history right. Our goal is to pinpoint the path of the tornado to the best of our ability and gather as much information as possible about the people affected so we can respectfully tell their stories and honor the memory of the lives lost.
In the case of the Knox County tornado, knowing the location of the Rutledge Pike Mobile Home Park was vital in determining its path. We will highlight this in our discrepancy section, but there are differences in the path length and location from the official sources. The SPC/NCDC provides only a starting point and states that the tornado traveled one mile. Thomas Grazulis notes a four-mile path that started seven miles northeast of Knoxville. He also mentioned the trailer park was at Sunrise on the Rutledge Pike.
Confusion increased as we dug into the newspaper accounts. The trailer park was referred to by two names and placed on two different roads: Corum Trailer Park off Rutledge Pike and Rutledge Pike Mobile Home Subdivision on Corum Drive. There is no Corum Drive (or Road, for that matter) near Rutledge Pike. A call was placed to the Knox County deeds and records office. Thank you to Ben Padgett, who did what he could to try to find the answer. We walked away empty-handed. We didn’t have enough to go on to nail down the name and location of the park.
After analyzing what we had, we honed in on the Plantation Acres Mobile Home Park off Roberts Road. Why?
- It was closer to the path extrapolated from the Super Outbreak map created by Ted Fujita.
- It was closer to the SPC point.
- It was near the Sunrise area mentioned by Thomas Grazulis.
- We verified from USGS imagery that the park existed 50 years ago.
There were problems with choosing this as the correct park: We could not find a Corum connection, and it was not off Rutledge Pike. It is located 0.4 miles northwest of that highway. The newspapers had mentioned the trailer park hit was near the city dump, but there was no evidence that Plantation Acres had ever been near a dump.
After hours of research and phone calls, we almost stopped here and were going to use Plantation Acres as our location. But there was one more call to make.
We talked to the property manager at Plantation Acres, who put us in touch with the original owner, Janet Hodge. Her family still lives near Plantation Acres and has lived in that area their entire life. We talked with Janet’s daughter, Sheila, who provided a wealth of information! She knew about this event and immediately stated Plantation Acres was not struck. The trailer park in question was almost 3 miles to the south-southwest, on the other side of Rutledge Pike. It is no longer there, and the property now belongs to The Poplar View Landfill.
Sheila recalled seeing the damage after it occurred. She also believed the subdivision’s name was the Rutledge Pike Mobile Home Park, so we decided to go with that name in this narrative. After talking to this credible witness, we finally honed in with confidence on the location of the trailer court. To strengthen the evidence, Nelson Tucker pulled USGS imagery from 1972 and 1975, which showed the trailer park.
We circled back with Ben at the deeds and record office. Now, with a definite address, we could find out who owned the property before the landfill. William Park Coram and his wife, Anna Kate, purchased the land in 1965. This solved the mystery of the “Corum” name used in the newspapers, except it was actually spelled “Coram.”
Aerial imagery showed trailers still on the property through at least 2002. It is unclear how many residents lived there if any at all. An expansion of the Poplar View Landfill occurred in 2003. By 2007, no trailers were seen on aerial imagery.
In Loving Memory
Edwin Francis “Butch” Morris Jr., 30 days
Tabetha Moran “Beth” Morris, 30 days
Discrepancies:
We gathered information for this event from the Storm Prediction Center (SPC) and National Climatic Data Center (NCDC) Databases, the April 1974 Storm Data Publication, Thomas Grazulis’ Significant Tornadoes: 1974-2022 publication, The Knoxville News-Sentinel publications, Sheila Hodge, and found the following differences:
Path Length:
- SPC, NCDC, and Storm Data list a 1-mile path length.
- Grazulis lists a 4-mile path length.
- Our findings list a path length of at least 4.3 miles based on reports from The Knoxville News-Sentinel, details provided by Sheila Hodge, and the distance between the Hargis/Hillard homes and the Rutledge Pike Mobile Home Park.
Start/End Coordinates:
- SPC and NCDC only list the beginning of the path at 36.10/-83.77.
- Our findings begin the path at ~36.016485/-83.870630 and end it at ~36.060017/-83.772901 based on reports from The Knoxville News-Sentinel, details provided by Sheila Hodge, and the distance between the Hargis/Hillard homes and the Rutledge Pike Mobile Home Park.
Rating:
- SPC and NCDC list a rating of F1.
- Grazulis lists a rating of F2.
Sources
The sources compiled in our research for this summary can be found here.
Questions or comments about this summary? Contact us here!
Note: There are some images/videos in our summaries that were licensed to us to be used only on this website. If you would like to use an image/video in your project or blog, please contact us and we will grant permission if possible.
Newspaper clips are embedded via newspapers.com. Please see their terms and conditions.
————————————————
Would you like to see more summaries like this one? Support Tornado Talk on Patreon! Become a Patron!
0 Comments