SPC Stats

Path length: 23.1 miles

Width:  300 yards

Fatalities:  2

Injuries:  7

Rating:  F3

County:  Nodaway, Worth, Harrison

Two tornadoes are found in The Storm Prediction Center (SPC) database for October 8, 1958:  An F2 in Illinois and the topic of our summary, an F3 that traveled through parts of Nodaway, Worth and Harrison Counties.  This was a fairly long track tornado.  The Storm Prediction Center has a path of 23.1 miles.  Thomas Grazulis in Significant Tornadoes lists slightly longer path at 35 miles.  When you plot the path details Grazulis has in his book, you actually get a path closer to 45 miles long. 

Gathering details from all of our sources, the tornado moved east-southeast from Pickering through the southern part of Parnell to about 8 miles southeast of Grant City.  From here, it tracked northeast to near Eagleville.

Per an article in The Maryville Daily Forum from October 10, 1958, 67 farmsteads had extensive damage in Nodaway and Worth Counties.  33 homes in the two counties were destroyed/damaged.  Twelve of the homes were located in the southern part of Parnell.  I could not find any damage information for the Eagleville area.

Seven injuries and two fatalities were reported.  It was noted in several newspapers that Mrs. Frank Porter (Shirley) died in her farm home SE of Grant City.  Here is a clip from the Chillicothe Constitution-Tribune:

Also near Grant City, a pickup truck was hurled into a ditch.  Pete Auten and three other members of his family suffered injuries.  Mr. Auten died 2 days later.

Tornado Path

Click map to enlarge.

The path in green shows the SPC coordinates:  Start: 40.42 / -94.63      End: 40.45 / -94.22

Corrected Coordinates based on Grazulis and damage reports.

Start:  40.443674/-94.844429   End: 40.457561/-93.998006.  Veer in path: 40.413994/-94.302905.

Note:  Exact tornado path may not be straight and/or continuous.

Newspaper Clippings

Discrepancies:

We gathered information for this event from the SPC & NCDC Databases, the October 1959 Climatological Data National Summary (CDNS) and Thomas Grazulis in Significant Tornadoes and found the following differences:

Note:  The NCDC entries for this event are not correct at all.  The lat/lon coordinates are off, they only have data for Nodaway and Harrison Counties and that data is incomplete. 

Path Length:

  • SPC has a 23.1 mile path length.
  • CDNS has a length at 26 miles.
  • Grazulis has a length at 35 miles.
  • When you plot what Grazulis lists in the path details in his book, the path length is closer to 45 miles.

Width:

  • CDNS has a range of width from 300 to 700 yards.
  • SPC and Grazulis have a width at 300 yards.

      Sources:

      The Storm Prediction Center

      NCDC Storm Events Database

      October 1958 Climatological Data National Summary

      newspapers.com

      Grazulis, Thomas P. (1993). Significant Tornadoes 1680-1991: A Chronology and Analysis of Events. St. Johnsbury, VT: The Tornado Project of Environmental Films. Page 1017.

      Did you enjoy reading about this event?  Help us create MORE summaries like this one by becoming a Supporter on Patreon!

      Questions or comments about this summary?  Contact us here!

      Join the tornado history discussion on our Discord Server!

      X