This summary explores tornadoes from February 1, 1955…..that are not a part of the official SPC Database.
Here are details from the February 1955 Climatological Data National Summary about what they denote as a wind and hail event:
There are only 2 tornadoes listed in the SPC database for February 1, 1955: An F2 in Bedford County, TN and an F1 in Grundy County, TN. The only mention of these twisters in the Climatological Data National Summary is in the above blurb. Not much detail at all.
In the summary above, there is a mention of enhanced damage at Commerce Landing in Tunica County and Lewisburg in DeSoto County, both in Mississippi.
The summary in 1955 states, “all debris carried eastward and investigation by meteorologists resulted in opinion storm was not a tornado.”
Thomas Grazulis in Significant Tornadoes believes the damage mentioned above was indeed due to 2 separate tornadoes: One in Commerce Landing/Robinsonville and one in Olive Branch/Lewisburg. Articles from newspapers also support tornadoes. I have researched several newspaper articles and included information and pictures in this summary. I also found an article where the Weather Bureau is interviewed saying it is not a tornado.
Note: It appears there were other tornadoes that occurred this day that are not in the official record. Grazulis mentions this briefly in his book. There are entries in the February 1955 Climatological Data National Summary that note damage in other areas (East Central Arkansas, Northern Alabama) but they state it was caused by damaging winds not a tornado. Here is a snapshot of those entries:
Grazulis commented on our tweet about this event in 2019. He said, “Motivation for not listing it as a tornado was 100% racial. Funnel was very visible. Previous comment was based on personal conversations with long time forecasters now deceased.”
Thunderstorms And Tornadoes Of February 1, 1955 – Monthly Weather Review
Additional evidence that there were tornado events on this day across parts of Arkansas, Mississippi and Alabama is shown in an article published in the Monthly Weather Review from February 1955 by Jean T. Lee from the Severe Local Storm Center, Weather Bureau Airport Station, Kansas City, MO.
Lee states in the introduction, “This series of severe local storms, accompanied by tornadoes, destructive winds, hail and heavy rain first struck near Marianna, Ark, at 1400 CST, roared through Commerce Landing, Miss., across northern Mississippi and on to near Huntsville, Ala., where they evidently dissipated around 1830 CST.”
Lee then provides a figure showing the location and times of reported storms in the midst of the Severe Local Storms Center tornado forecast area on February 1, 1955. See image below extracted from the article. The forecast area is outlined.
The rest of the paper describes the parameters that were analyzed to forecast tornadoes on this day. The entire article is archived on the AMS website. Find it here!
Tornado #1: Commerce Landing/Robinsonville
Time 1420. Path length of 8 miles. Max width was 600 yards. 141 injuries. Rating of F3.
Grazulis notes the tornado cut a path from Commerce Landing, 5 miles West of Robinsonville to Clark. We based our path map on that information. There are no official coordinates. Note: “Clark” is one of several plantation communities that no longer exist.
Fatalities: Grazulis does not give an exact number of fatalities. The February 1955 summary states there were 20 deaths, mainly school children at Commerce Landing.
This is the full summary from Significant Tornadoes. We have permission to present it in its entirety:
Seen first as a “well defined cone-shaped funnel” over the Mississippi River, this tornado cut a path from Commerce Landing, 5m W of Robinsonville, to Clark. Most of the deaths were in a plantation school, and several people died in the 45 tenant homes that were destroyed. About 50 other homes were damaged. The school was rebuilt, and named after the teacher who lost her life trying to get the children into ditches along the road. Her car was carried 300 yards. The body of one dead child was carried over a half mile. Despite the fact that a funnel was seen, that heavy objects were thrown long distances, and that the tornado was in a forecast box, the event was not officially called a tornado. A survey team stated that since all debris was thrown in one direction, the event should not be listed as a tornado. Mississippi losses this day totaled $300,000.
Tornado #2: Olive Branch/Lewisburg
Time 1445. Path length of 2 miles. Max width was 100 yards. 25 injuries. Rating of F2.
Full summary from Significant Tornadoes:
Moved E, passing north of Lewisburg. A plantation school between Olive Branch and Lewisburg was destroyed. The teacher and two students were killed. This tornado is also not on official lists.
We plotted Lewisburg and Olive Branch on the map. Path unknown.
Newspapers.com is a wonderful source for historical narratives. I reviewed several articles and here is some of the information found. There were so many devastating stories from these tornadoes but also stories of heroism. This is just a small sampling of what I found:
From the Clarion-Ledger, 02 Feb 1955, Wed, Page 1
- At least 25 dead across the Midsouth, many of them school children
- Main tornado, “a full-blown giant” hit the Commerce Landing, MS area.
- 22 were killed
- Approx 45 houses most of them tenant building on the Leatherman and Abbay plantations were destroyed.
- 2nd tornado near Olive Branch
- Red Cross said ~100 were injured in both town
- “Officials asked the 3rd Army to send 100 cots and 280 blankets from its Memphis storehouses.”
- Also a mention of a tornado near Marianna, AR.
- “The twister struck the Leatherwood school shortly before classes would have ended for the day. Bodies from the school were blown from 200 to 2,000 yards away.”
- There was a witness in Olive Branch that said, “a darkness thick as night closed down just before the tornado roared out of the rain and swept Wiggins elementary school away.”
From the Greenwood Commonwealth, 02 Feb 1955, Wed, Page 1
From the Enterprise-Journal, 04 Feb 1955, Fri, Page 1
From the Delta Democrat-Times, 04 Feb 1955, Fri, Page 1
From the Clarion-Ledger on Feb 12, 1955:
Rep. Tom Garrott, Tunica County, offered a resolution that was unanimously adopted by the house to memorialize the school teacher who helped save the students in Commerce Landing.
An article was posted in the Greenwood Commonwealth on Feb 8, 1955 quoting a Weather Bureau meteorologist and how this was not tornado damage. Here is the article.
Photos from Miscellaneous Newspapers:
Grazulis, Thomas P. (1993). Significant Tornadoes 1680-1991: A Chronology and Analysis of Events. St. Johnsbury, VT: The Tornado Project of Environmental Films. Page 985.
Lee, J.T. 1955. “Thunderstorms and Tornadoes of February 1, 1955.” Monthly Weather Review
“2 Twisters Hit In North Delta.” Clarion-Ledger (Jackson, MS), February 2, 1955. https://www.newspapers.com/newspage/185641155/ (accessed January 31, 2018).
“Tornado Spreads Death And Destruction Over Northwest Delta.” The Greenwood Commonwealth (Greenwood, MS), February 2, 1955. https://www.newspapers.com/newspage/253199955/ (accessed January 31, 2018).
Emmerich, Oliver. “High-Lights in the Headlines.” Enterprise-Journal (McComb, MS), February 4, 1955. https://www.newspapers.com/newspage/252075717/ (accessed January 31, 2018).
“School May Be Named For Tornado Hero.” The Delta Democrat-Times (Greenville, MS), February 4, 1955. https://www.newspapers.com/newspage/11425064/ (accessed January 31, 2018).
“Death-Dealing Storm Was Not A Tornado.” The Greenwood Commonwealth (Greenwood, MS), February 8, 1955. https://www.newspapers.com/newspage/253200651/ (accessed January 31, 2018).
Did you enjoy reading about this event? Help us create MORE summaries like this one by becoming a Supporter on Patreon!
Questions or comments about this summary? Contact us here: https://tornadotalk.com/contact-us/
Join the tornado history discussion on our Discord Channel: https://discordapp.com/invite/Xm43dQj